When I look up the daylily 'Cindy's Eye' which I own, I am not showing in the list of owners. I can't figure out why it is not showing?

When you scroll down the entry, does it still have the blue "Add this plant to your list" button?
Daylily (Hemerocallis 'Cindy's Eye')

No, it shows to be in my list.

I just looked at you list and don't see it.
http://garden.org/lists/view/S...

http://garden.org/lists/view/S...
It is just down the page and is listed under rust resistant daylilies

Nope, that link is empty for me and the link I added is the public list you have of all the plants and it's not there. There must be some kind of glitch.
What I would do is go into your edit mode or click on the " In your list!" link from the entry and change the status back to "choose from below" and then uncheck it from whatever category you have it from and then click to save your changes. Then go back to the entry and add it again, checking the 'Have' status and whatever category you want and then save it.

I bet it's privacy settings. You probably added it to a category that you marked as private. That'll prevent it from showing on public places.

I did all that, and it still did not show I had the plant. I deleted all the info in my plant list, and entered the info all over, still does not show I own it.

Sorry, I can't seem to find where to mark it private or not? Where do I go?

Finally found it, thanks!

there it is!
And I always forget about that privacy thing, could have saved us a lot of back and forth mystery!