I understand this Joshua, but when I am searching for something on the net, I back out of anything that requires a log in...if for no other reason, just to avoid more junk mail. This site has always be easy to access without giving up your history. It's free, but doesn't require all your info, which makes it popular. Yes we know it doesn't live on love alone, but I'm sure there are lots of folks out there that just won't fill in all the blanks. That's why I suggested "where the plant is located".. That won't work in the Ask a question forum when someone is asking about their garden, but again, they can compromise. Making it mandatory will likely scare some people off. Just my opinion.