Thank you! Recently I started saving a copy of the banners away from the original photo and keeping the original photo number. There were a couple of banners I wanted to check something and just gave up finding the right photo. After feeling like I was trying to fit a square peg in a round hole with another image from a bit different angle, I finally found the right one!
This is the one that was slightly off and I just couldn't match it up:
I must have walked all over the island, and on the way off again, stopped at a bit different angle to take almost the same shot, but without the flat sky from the earlier one. They both were taken across the lagoon from the island:
Edit to add the date of the photos was March 25, 2012, with my little Sony WX-9 that I actually loved because of the size.