Hi Tiffany, to me your 1st Haworthia photo looks like H limifolia (on the left) and H cymbiformis var. cymbiformis on the right.
I did surgery on my Haworthias , and was hesitant to share photos but decided "why not?"
I've had most of these for 2 years.
I cut off the tops and planted them next to the rooted plant in hopes that it will stimulate base growth! These have only been growing up, and not filling in!
H glabrata
H limifolia
Now for the non surgicalized ones!
H cooperi with a bloom and more coming!
H retusa 'White Ghost'
H fasciata (zebra plant)
and finally a tiny one, its in a 3 inch pot, to give you and idea of how little!
closeup
I have several more! I love these plants!