Just a grain of salt...
I try to avoid the criterion around classes...it can be misleading. The rose bushes themselves don't know anything about their identity, name family or provenance....
So my alternative way is to look at each individual as it makes progress or not. Sometimes as you say my bushes grow backwards, and eventually give up their ghost...
However even then there's something extra to learn...
I do grow Mme Isaac Pereire, which ought to be kind of a climber ( the sages at HMF say so). My specimen is own root and still behaves as a mid sized bush. I've got it 4 seasons ago. The first season it didn't do well so I lifted it and placed it in a grow bag under a more shaded position. It liked that and bloomed nicely still potted in its grow bag. This season, just in the leafing out stage, I will plant it again in ground in a mid shade situation. Perhaps it needs more root space under and the bag doesn't allow enough room for it to throw long canes. I provided a good general fertilizer two years in a row and it has doubled in size. When planting I will provide a very generous supply of organic matter. I use raw wool as mulch both in hole under the bush when planting and around the top of crown as a scarf. On top of the wool I add an inch of leaf mould and another of compost or horse manure. So if anything my roses are well fed! One variable less ...
After these 4/5 years of growing roses my first bet will be always good garden soil. Like so many here at the RF I have a very poor soil ( sandy) to start with, that dries up in minutes after watering. So the second issue is how frequently can you water your roses. Water stress is a real problem in my yard. In comparison with my other HT's MIP is more water demanding. So that may be your second cause of low productivity.
All rose growers have been grappling with climate change worldwide...
. At least for me, I can't change the climate ...( unless I grow my roses under cover which sometimes I do). So the alternative is figuring how to move along climate change trying to provide the conditions that suit best for each individual, by carefully watching how they are faring season after season. Yes, that may imply moving about roses. Some roses actually benefit from shade ( Clg Souvenir de la Malmaison or Mme Plantier). This I discovered by moving my potted bags around and found where each did best!
Like you, I've got nearly 400 bushes to deal with. Not all my bushes receive my TLC as they ought to in terms of my attention. Each bush has something to teach me all along. So when something goes below prime, then my attention starts to switch towards deepening my observation skills around it. Like any gardener anywhere, I still cope with vast ammounts of unanswered questions. Not always the right answer pops up quickly...
most take years because:
each garden is unique as is each gardener
Arturo
PS I realized that I didn't mention one other factor: the aspect. My MIP is placed facing a west aspect. So it gets full sun all afternoon. It is cool in the morning under the projected shade of some scots pine. I also want to recall that I share the same climate pattern as bart does: mediterranean which means 0 rain during the long summer months, but temperature wise considerably cooler on the average to her place in Tuscany. I have to irrigate everything, otherwise no garden...just a desert!